Star Tribune: In Senate race, the friendliest microphones can come with the biggest headaches
Associate Professor Benjamin Toff is interviewed about political candidates reaching voters through podcasts and social media rather than more traditional media.
Michele Tafoya, left, and Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan. (Leila Navidi/The Minnesota Star Tribune, Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
The Minnesota Star Tribune
For a candidate running statewide in Minnesota, an hour on a friendly podcast can be a tempting proposition. There’s time to talk about health care and the cost of raising a family, an audience willing to listen and little risk of an unwelcome question. It’s the sort of exposure campaigns spend considerable money trying to buy.
Then someone goes looking through the hosts’ old Facebook posts.
That was the unexpected complication for Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan after a conservative news outlet raised questions about her appearance on a podcast hosted by two suburban Minnesota women whose social media account had published posts expressing a wish for President Donald Trump to die.
Her Republican opponent, Michele Tafoya, has encountered that problem from the other side of the microphone. Before running for U.S. Senate, the former sports broadcaster hosted hundreds of political interviews, including sympathetic conversations with people prosecuted for their roles in the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol. Those exchanges have since drawn scrutiny of their own.
Both cases illustrate the increasingly complicated bargain facing candidates who venture beyond traditional news outlets in search of voters.
Podcasts and partisan programs offer access to audiences that might otherwise be difficult to reach, often on unusually favorable terms. They also create a permanent record of conversations and associations that can be revisited long after the microphones are turned off.
And as campaigns find more ways to communicate directly with voters, they have more freedom to decide which journalists — and which questions — they can afford to ignore.
Following the audience
Benjamin Toff, a University of Minnesota journalism researcher who studies news audiences, said campaigns are responding to a gradual but consequential change in how Americans consume information. Voters increasingly encounter news through social media rather than seeking it directly from established outlets.
Podcasts offer something more than another audience. They give politicians room to speak at length, often with hosts whose listeners feel a personal connection to them.
Candidates have “a lot more time to sort of speak in their own voice,” Toff said. Campaigns may also hope that the trust listeners place in a host will “rub off” on their guests.
There is another attraction: control.